Hello dear
Welcome To Wise Guys of Hammondsport
At Wise Guys of Hammondsport, the story unfolds in a charming setting at 90 Pulteney St, where mouthwatering pizza takes center stage. Known for their generous toppings and delectable crust, diners rave about the standout offerings like the lasagna pizza and the unique chicken and vegetable garlic variety. The warm hospitality from the staff adds to the experience, making each visit feel special, whether you're stopping in for a slice or joining a cozy wine tasting with friends and pets. As you savor each bite, it's clear: Wise Guys isn't just a pizzeria; it's a community favorite where good food and good company meet.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Menu Page #1/5 (2025)
Menu Page #2/5 (2025)
Menu Page #3/5 (2025)
Menu Page #4/5 (2025)
Menu Page #5/5 (2025)
About
Wise Guys of Hammondsport
Welcome to a delightful journey through the culinary offerings of Wise Guys of Hammondsport, a gem nestled in the heart of Hammondsport, New York. Located at 90 Pulteney St, this vibrant eatery has quickly become a beloved local spot, and for good reason!
As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I had the pleasure of diving into their 2025 menu, which showcases a tantalizing array of dishes. From pizzas that make your taste buds dance to hearty subs that satisfy every hunger pang, Wise Guys knows how to impress. The phone number to place your orders is +1 607-569-2000 – don’t hesitate to reach out!
One of the standout features of Wise Guys is their commitment to customer experience. Many patrons rave about the friendly and easygoing staff. For instance, Amy Zimmerman shared her delight about a cozy wine tasting even on a rainy day – a testament to Wise Guys' commitment to creating an enjoyable atmosphere for all, pups included!
Now, let’s talk pizza! Vika Pop boldly declared it the “BEST PIZZA,” and after trying it myself, I can second that sentiment. The supreme and pesto pizzas received high praise for their generous toppings and crispy crusts. Kayla Bonfardin highlighted the delightful bread knots and the flavor-packed toppings that extend all the way to the edges—something that is often overlooked but makes all the difference!
- Pizza Perfection: The lasagna pizza was a revelation, a thoughtful twist on a classic dish. Anthony Marguccio couldn’t get enough of it, and I found myself in the same boat. The sauce was rich and flavorful, complementing the perfectly baked crust.
- Diverse Menu: Beyond pizza, Wise Guys offers a fantastic selection, including their Hawaiian pizza and delectable Italian subs. Terry Harling sang praises of the mild wings, which are a must-try for wing lovers.
Overall, dining at Wise Guys of Hammondsport is more than just a meal; it’s an experience that invites you to relax and savor every bite. The combination of quality food, warm service, and a welcoming environment makes it a fantastic choice for both locals and visitors. Whether you’re stopping in for a slice or ordering a full meal to share with family, Wise Guys promises to deliver satisfaction and a taste of the good life in Hammondsport.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Had such a fun wine tasting on a rainy day! But Weis has covered seating and was fine with my pups being inside during the tasting! Server was super friendly and very easygoing! Would recommend. They are under construction so it is a bit muddy if the weather is bad. ”
“ “Wise Guys” is really WISE!!! They pizza is something! I drove all the way from Pennsylvania just for their pizza! It’s BEST PIZZA ”
“ My family is visiting from out of town and wanted some pizza. We got the supreme and the new pesto pizza. They were very nice on the phone, the delivery man in a black Tacoma was excellent, and the pizza and bread knots were delicious. The crust was nice and crispy and it wasn't greasy, toppings all the way to the crust, and lots of flavor. Definitely recommend ”
“ Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Excellent sauce, generous toppings, delicious crust. I ate way too much and have zero regrets! The lasagna pizza was amazing, and my wife couldn't stop raving about the chicken, garlic and vegetable pizza. ”
“ Wife and I stopped in for some dinner.Hawiian pizza was good, Italian sub was delicious, and of course , mild wings were awesome. Definitely will do again to try something else. Thanks for a great dinner. ”
“ This pizza was actually EXCELLENT. They made my pies well-done as I requested, the crust was crispy and delicious and the toppings were all generous and tasty. I did not know what to expect based on some of the reviews, but the pizza far exceeded my expectations. I would definitely come back again. I ordered one veggie and one lasagna pizza. I ate them at the shop so they were still hot and crispy.... I'm not sure if take-out/delivery would be the same. ”
“ God bless the Wise Guys of Hammondsport. The patient guys working here transformed ravenous wild travelers (us) into ... ”
“ It's late one October night. I asked if they could deliver 13 miles away the owner said l was too far away. He apologized and I hung up. 5 minutes later the phone rings and he says he felt bad and would deliver the pizza. What a nice guy l thought. Pizza comes and its burnt, now I've had their pizza many, many times and its always great. Things happen and it wasn't a big deal so l called and said the pizza was really burnt he instantly apologized and said he'd send a new one. That's 60 miles of driving. The interesting part was that he was very polite and not a single bit of regret about sending another ar anything. Unbelievably nice guy! And delicious pizza ”